BuySI

Mariners Harbor / Graniteville

North Shore
Buyer'sSeller's0 (Buyer's)50 (Balanced)100 (Seller's)68.6

Seller's Market

Stable

Composite score combining supply, pricing dynamics, and speed

Mariners Harbor / Graniteville is a seller's market. Homes sell in 58 days on average, 1% under asking.

Market Metrics

Pricing

Median Sale Price

$558K

+0.1%YoY

Avg $/Sq Ft

$431

Sale-to-List Ratio

99.2%

% Over Asking

0.3%

% With Price Cuts

N/A

Speed

Median Days on Market

58 days

Sold in <14 Days

0.2%

Sold in <30 Days

N/A

Supply

Active Inventory

35

New Listings

N/A

Months of Supply

1.1

Absorption Rate

94.3%

Volume

Homes Sold

33

Adjust Assumptions

$

Mariners Harbor / Graniteville median: $558,273

0%Loan: $447K50%
2%10%

Required in FEMA flood zones. Not all areas of SI need this.

Monthly Cost Breakdown

Mortgage (P&I)
$2,823/mo($33,875/yr)
Property Tax
$465/mo($5,583/yr)
Homeowner's Insurance
$175/mo($2,104/yr)
Flood Insurance
$292/mo($3,500/yr)

Zone AE — $2,000-$5,000/yr

Commute Costs
$127/mo($1,524/yr)

Express Bus

TOTAL MONTHLY COST
$3,882/mo

$46,586/yr

Mortgage (P&I)
Property Tax
Homeowner's Insurance
Flood Insurance
Commute Costs

Estimates for planning purposes. Actual costs may vary. Property tax uses a ~1% approximation; NYC assessments differ. Flood insurance ranges reflect typical NFIP premiums.

Price Trends

Median Sale Price

Avg Price Per Sq Ft

Days on Market

Median Days on Market

Sale-to-List Ratio

Sale-to-List Ratio

Supply & Demand

Supply & Demand

Property Types & Price Distribution

Property Types

Single Family$527K median
Two/Three Family$590K median
Condo$303K median
Vacant Land$479K median
Tax Class 1 Other$405K median
STORE BUILDINGS$435K median
FACTORIES$300K median
Elevator Rental$900K median
COMMERCIAL VACANT LAND$100 median

Price Distribution

Flood Risk Assessment

Low Risk10% of this area is in a FEMA flood zone

Primary FEMA Zone

Zone X (minimal flood hazard)

Est. Annual Flood Insurance

$400 $800 / year

Area in flood zone10%

Mariners Harbor has some tidal wetland areas near the Arthur Kill. Graniteville is mostly elevated and low-risk.

Look up your address on FEMA Flood Map Service

Recent Sales

AddressSale PriceSq Ft$/Sq FtLand Sq FtYear BuiltSale DateTypeUnits
$730,0001,500$4872,5002024May 29, 2026Single Family1
$540,0001,250$4322,5201965May 21, 2026Single Family1
$540,0001,192$4535,3551925May 19, 2026Single Family1
$555,0002004May 13, 2026Condo1
$585,0001,300$4501,5552000May 8, 2026Single Family1
$620,0001,244$4987,7521899May 8, 2026Single Family1
$820,0001,584$5183,2502013May 7, 2026Two/Three Family2
$310,0003,750May 1, 2026Vacant Land0
$310,0003,750May 1, 2026Vacant Land0
$660,0001,176$5611,5082004May 1, 2026Two/Three Family2
$718,0001,348$5335,0631920Apr 29, 2026Two/Three Family2
$580,0001,300$4461,3402000Apr 24, 2026Single Family1
$715,0001,350$5301,3652000Apr 15, 2026Two/Three Family2
$440,0001,350$3261,5002000Apr 13, 2026Two/Three Family2
$540,0001,020$5295,4721910Apr 13, 2026Single Family1
$423,0001,408$3001,1361899Apr 10, 2026Single Family1
$475,0001,470$3231,2801992Apr 1, 2026Single Family1
$790,0001,920$4115,3551930Mar 31, 2026Two/Three Family2
$730,0001,080$6764,9001955Mar 30, 2026Single Family1
$400,0001,408$2841,1361899Mar 30, 2026Single Family1
$545,0001,000$5454,2201997Mar 27, 2026Single Family1
$465,0001,974$2367,7521915Mar 24, 2026Single Family1
$400,0001,403$2851,3861991Mar 23, 2026Single Family1
$832,0001,584$5253,7752006Mar 17, 2026Two/Three Family2
$770,0001,800$4283,3751989Mar 13, 2026Two/Three Family2

Showing 25 of 100 sales

Neighborhood Profile

Population

27,400

Median Income

$50,000

Owner-Occupied

38.0%

Median Age

34.0

Owner vs Renter

Staten Island FerryN/A

Ferry service available from St. George only

SIM Express Bus60 min
Driving42 min

Via Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge

Estimated one-way travel times to Lower Manhattan during weekday rush hour.